‘Stunned for many reasons’: St. Columban pastor reacts to new pope

Fr. Bryan Ochs not getting ‘worked up’ over AI-generated image of Pope Trump

Posted

On May 8, the Roman Catholic Church elected Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost as its new pope.

Pope Leo XIV is the first American pope in the history of the Catholic Church, which spans some 2,000 years. Born in Chicago, the new pope is also a citizen of Peru.

Fr. Bryan Ochs, local pastor of St. Columban Catholic Church in Yelm, expressed surprise over the recent selection. In a letter to parishioners, Ochs said he was “stunned for many reasons.”

“I didn’t think that we would see white smoke that soon,” Ochs wrote. “I also didn’t expect an American. A couple weeks ago I said, ‘Expect the unexpected.’ Well, that certainly proved to be true.”

Ochs said that he thought Cardinal Prevost, in his role as prefect of the Dicastery of Bishops, along with Pope Francis, often selected solid, well-liked pastors to be bishops, and that there didn’t seem to be any ideological preference among their selections.

“This is actually a bit of a shift,” Ochs wrote to his parishioners. “Prior to Pope Francis, the path to becoming a bishop didn’t often pass through parish life. It passed through high level chancery positions and teaching posts in seminaries. Thus, many of our bishops really didn’t have a good grasp of parish life and ministry, which often led to conflict and tension between priests and their bishops. Cardinal Prevost and Pope Francis focused on finding successful pastors to become bishops, and I think new bishops ordained in the last five years or so have been good picks.”

Ochs said that, while he thought Pope Leo XIV spoke “excellent Italian,” he welcomed the pope’s decision to use a script for his “first address to the world.”

“Some of the most confusing moments of the Francis Pontificate were moments in which he spoke off the cuff, opening his words to unintended interpretations by the media. Pope Leo XIV didn’t strike me as being that type of man. I think that when Pope Leo speaks it will be very thoughtful and eloquent.”



Ochs concluded his letter by saying there were many things to be optimistic about regarding the church’s future.

In a statement released May 8, Archbishop Paul D. Etienne of Seattle called Pope Leo XIV “an amazing choice as the next successor of Peter.”

“The name chosen tells us he will put the social teachings of the Church at the heart of this pontificate,” Etienne said. “I have found this man in my brief encounters to be humble, affable, confident and competent in carrying out his responsibilities. We have hopeful and bright days ahead!”

Many Catholics, meanwhile, have expressed disapproval of a recent AI-generated image of President Donald Trump dressed as the pope. The image was shared by official White House social media accounts just days after Trump attended Pope Francis’s funeral in Vatican City.

On May 3, the New York State Catholic Conference wrote on X: “There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr. President. We just buried our beloved Pope Francis and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St. Peter. Do not mock us.”

Opinion on the matter is varied, with other Catholics dismissing it as a joke. When asked about the image by the media, Trump said he had “nothing to do with it.”

In an email to the Nisqually Valley News on May 10, Fr. Ochs had this to say:
“Many people expressing outrage over the AI image of Trump in Media and Government have said and done offensive things about other Popes and other important aspects of our faith, so I’m not letting myself or my parishioners get worked up about (it).”

Fr. Bryan Ochs has been pastor of St. Columban since July 2024. He is also the pastor of Sacred Heart in Lacey and St. Peter in Tenino.