Fournier: Local food, national security — what the beef debate gets wrong

Posted

When President Trump recently proposed importing more Argentine beef to “lower prices,” it sent cattle markets into a frenzy. At first glance, that might sound like a good deal: cheaper burgers at the grocery store. But that is where the story ends, and where the real problem begins.

This proposal has highlighted a large danger in our food systems, one that we’ve been working on here at home for over a decade. The danger lies in how our food system is built — in supply chains that are too long, too fragile and too far from home.

Four multinational corporations control more than 80 percent of the U.S. meatpacking industry. They can import cheaper beef, sometimes labeling it “Product of USA” after minimal processing. That loophole undercuts American ranchers while keeping corporate profits high.
Meanwhile, small and mid-sized processors, the ones that keep jobs and value in our communities, are disappearing. COVID-19-era issues showed us how risky that concentration is from a logistical perspective. When one major plant shut down, grocery shelves went bare. We saw the same thing with baby formula and even toilet paper.

The problem is not supply. It is over-centralization. When too much power sits in too few hands, the whole system is one bad week away from breaking.

Food security is national security. And it starts with rebuilding local resilience.

Here in Southwest Washington, we did not wait for disaster to strike. Over the last decade, local leaders, farmers and economic developers have been laying the groundwork for a resilient regional food system.

In 2016, the Thurston Economic Development Council (EDC) published a landmark report outlining how to strengthen our local food economy (this report can still be found on their website). It called for preserving farmland, expanding food processing, improving coordination and developing critical infrastructure such as food hubs and distribution networks. That vision became our roadmap. Today, it is coming to life.

The Southwest Washington Growers Cooperative, formed in 2019, now includes more than 30 farmer and producer members. Its Food Hub, launched during COVID with a Department of Labor grant through PacMtn, aggregates and distributes food across several counties. It currently serves tribes, employers and nonprofits while opening new markets for local growers.

The co-op also operates the Southwest Washington Grain Project, the region’s first public grain storage and rail transloading facility. It helps mid-sized farms reach local processors and strengthen Washington’s grain economy. These efforts are not just economic development. They are community insurance policies.

At the heart of this regional work is the Agriculture Innovation Park in Tenino, a 13-acre public-private development dedicated to helping local agriculture thrive.

The park is home to:
• Colvin Ranch Provisions, offering beef and an ever-growing variety of 100 percent locally made food products.
• HOTBABE Hot Sauce, a local food manufacturer that sources peppers from regional farms through the Food Hub, is an incubator success story for a small, women- and minority-owned business.



• Simply Organic Café brings a farm-to-table dining experience to town.
• Stone City Event Center expands agritourism and community events.
• The Thurston EDC provides business technical support, tenant recruitment and project management.

Federal and state investments are helping this vision grow. Congresswoman Marie Gluesenkamp Perez secured $500,000 for a food incubator and workforce development programs, and she has been advocating to bring another $2.5 million to build the necessary utilities for the meat processing facilities. State legislators Peter Abbarno and John Braun helped secure $3.6 million in state appropriations, and the City of Tenino partnered with Washington state for a $1.5 million CERB loan and grant. Through public-private-nonprofit partnerships, this park is a center for agricultural innovation and resiliency.

Future funding could support a USDA-certified meat processing facility that would serve 14 counties. This proposed facility speaks directly to the issue that is being debated nationally right now. It would reduce costs, shorten wait times and keep food processing local.

Resilience also depends on people. The EDC and its partners have been expanding workforce development opportunities in agriculture. Through grant funding the EDC will be helping with workforce development to ensure there are adequately trained professionals in the region that will be able to run the future meat processing facility. With an expanded focus on agricultural workforce development, the EDC will soon host a regional workforce convening at the Ag Park to connect employers, educators and jobseekers. When local people can build local food careers, our communities grow stronger.

None of this happens alone. The Thurston WSU Extension and the Northwest Agriculture Business Center have been critical partners in everything related to regional agriculture development. The Southwest Washington Growers Cooperative, Food Hub and Grain Project would not exist without their collaboration and support.

If you are a policymaker, keep this momentum going. Expand rural zoning options that make essential agricultural infrastructure possible. Support workforce development and small processors. Reinstate strong country-of-origin labeling so consumers know what they are buying and where it comes from (pork and beef are currently exempt from this labeling).

If you are a consumer, you have power, too. Every time you buy from a farmers’ market, join a CSA, or support local producers through the Food Hub, you are investing in community resilience.

If you are a producer or entrepreneur, there is room for you at the table. The Agriculture Innovation Park and regional partners are helping businesses start, grow, and stay local.

We do not have to imagine what a resilient food system looks like. We can see it happening right here in Southwest Washington. Now it is time to keep building, together. Local food is not just about what is on our plate. It is about independence, security and taking care of one another when times get tough.

•••

Wayne Fournier is a Thurston County commissioner, former Tenino mayor, firefighter and lifelong community advocate.